Page 1 of 1

The contradictory Trial quest in the EU edition

PostPosted: November 22nd, 2026, 1:17 am
by dragon5145
Having recently been rereading the 2nd edition EU rule book from the the Inn, I was surprised to see the designers appear to have managed to contradict themselves as early as the first quest. When reading from the start it appears "The Trial" was meant to be the introductory game for this edition as a replacement for the arena of 1st edition. Might explain why it uses every piece of furniture and monster type. The rule book exlpicitly states that the only actions in the introductory game are move and fight. It goes further to say the only cards that are used are the monster cards. No spells no treasure deck. This is further reinforced by the section "The Trial" that says your ready for your 1st quest being followed by the section The Full Game that starts with "Now you have played your first Quest you are ready to learn the rest of the game rules.". It is then the the rulebook goes on to explain, magic, searches, and traps in their respective sections. Has anyone ever played it like that, seems it might be dangerous but doable with EU 1BP monsters, NA monster BP I shudder to think about it. Any way back to my point about the contradiction, why the quest notes for treasure, the rulebook already said for the introductory game move and fight are the only player action. If they can't search the quest notes are meaningless.

Re: The contradictory Trial quest in the EU edition

PostPosted: November 22nd, 2026, 2:56 am
by Agente Cooper
I believe the contradiction lies in the US version. Let me explain: it was originally released in the UK, and it wasn't a mission that was part of the main storyline; it wasn't designed to be "beaten" in the traditional sense. Instead, it was essentially a test mission intended to be played while still reading through the rulebook. The US edition adapted it as the first mission, which—erroneously—made it the most difficult one of all.

Furthermore, there’s the issue of "searching for treasure." As you rightly pointed out, this quest is played before the rules even explain what "searching for treasure" is—or how that action replaces an "attack." This is because "opening a chest" isn't considered an "action" in the modern sense we use for board games. If we put ourselves in the shoes of players back in 1990, you would simply walk up to a chest and open it to see what’s inside—whatever the Game Master finds listed in their quest book.

Re: The contradictory Trial quest in the EU edition

PostPosted: November 22nd, 2026, 6:58 am
by dragon5145
Sorry if it seemed otherwise, but when I saw what appeared to be a rules contradiction I didn't consider the NA rules was just going by exactly what the 2nd rulebook said. Though your comments did get me thinking, maybe they just treated it as part of movement like opening a door, heck both chests and doors have hinges might as well throw in the cupboard too :D . Would have been nice if opening chests was included in the moving around the board section like doors if that was what they intended. If that was the mechanic it would go a long way to explain traps next to chests while the chest itself is not trapped in later quests.

Though there is still the contradiction that they seem to include chest in treasure search later in the full game rules. If opening chests are not counted as part of the search action because it's not an "action", then does anything found in them really count as the special treasure for that room? In the quest book several notes say something along the line of "if a player searches for treasure he finds x", however this phrasing never occurs for chests. I would say yes, but it does make me think about it.

Re: The contradictory Trial quest in the EU edition

PostPosted: November 22nd, 2026, 11:18 am
by Parzival
In the 2021 edition, The Trial excludes searching for traps and secret doors, but searching for Treasure is still a part of the quest. Otherwise, it’s treated as a straight forward quest, same as the rest.
The rulebook does have Zargon read the Quest Book and set up the quest before reading the rest of the rules, but the rules don’t really otherwise tie any progression to “The Trial” quest itself. The “instructional” level of the quest seems largely nominal.

Re: The contradictory Trial quest in the EU edition

PostPosted: November 22nd, 2026, 11:20 am
by lestodante
Rules from 1st 1989 edition and 2nd 1990 edition and Game-System (1990 North American version) are slightly different. 2021 edition is taking from 1990 NA version with some extra adjustments.
Anyway, there are still so many contradictory rules in HeroQuest and that's why forum like this are helpful! :mrgreen:

Re: The contradictory Trial quest in the EU edition

PostPosted: November 22nd, 2026, 4:39 pm
by dragon5145
lestodante wrote:Anyway, there are still so many contradictory rules in HeroQuest and that's why forum like this are helpful! :mrgreen:


Brilliant point. I always appreciate all the different ideas and ways members reconcile the contradictions, becomes a plethora of inspiration.