Revised Rulebook - CLOSED

[Davane]

May I humbly suggest that you take a look over my HQ CERB, and see if there's any cross-over between these two projects? I would greatly appreciate some thorough feedback, and it might make things easier if we are both doing the same thing.

My hope with the HQ CERB is to unify the UK(EU) and US(NA) Rules, complete with components, so that groups can choose a mixture of core and "house" rules in order to specifically recreate any version of HQ to date.

[Bareheaded Warrior]

Davane, I've reviewed your HQ CERB and I like the clear look and feel, but I think that we are doing two subtly different things.

Your rules merge the UK and US versions where they are the same and state the two different versions, side by side, where they differ, but I am attempting to produce a single version of the rules considering the best of both versions (unless that too is your ultimate end-point).

Originally, I was theming this as UK/EU version 3, but the rules more closely resembled the US version than the UK/EU version, so it is now more like US version 2.

Essentially, I have taken the US rulebook and card text (and the rules and card text from some of the expansions) rolled it into a single document, then re-arranged it into a book, chapter, and verse layout to make it easier to use as a reference material, in that you can quote book, chapter and verse numbers to refer to a specific rule.

I have then looked at each problem that I have found with the rules during play and/or through this forum and where the problem is one of lack of clarity in the rules leading to different groups playing with different interpretations then I have used this forum to discuss the issue and try and find a balanced solution that works (in actual gameplay as well as logically, without any unintended consequences)

Aside from lack of clarity in the rules another common issue is a lack of consistency, both within the rule book and between the rule book and expansions, so I have tried to make that consistent too.

Little in my version is new, although the search action has been rewritten completely, it is more just working through each problem and extensively play-testing a number of different solutions and then documenting which one works!

[Bareheaded Warrior]

Daedalus, my revision of the searching and trap rules means that you get a chance to 'detect & disarm' a trap at the point at when you step on that square during movement or are placed there during a search only, if successful the trap is disarmed / made safe and ceases to exist, if you are not successful then the trap springs and for falling block the 'rubble' is placed.

This means that the situation that you raised never occurs as there is no mechanism for removing something placed as a result of a trap being sprung, no mechanism to remove a 'rubble' counter or a pit counter once it has been placed, the 'detection and disarm' roll only applies when you are stood on a square that contain a unsprung trap.

[Bareheaded Warrior]

This topic has now been closed as the project has been superseded by Polishing the Second Edition

The problems around searching for and disarming traps mentioned above are covered under Problem #20: Searching for and disarming traps on the above topic.