Page 1 of 1

Elf & Thief concepts

PostPosted: May 7th, 2024, 9:28 pm
by burglekutt
I want my Elf to be a MOSTLY missile firing character. A 2Att Bow in the Elfs hands is now 3Att.
Merits.
Bow= 3Att first shot, 2Att second shot.
Crossbow= 4Att every other round?

Flaws.
No Battle axe or Plate mail.

As with all our concepts we judge that for every BodyPoint, AttackDie or DefendDie less than the Barbarian, other heros should gain a bonus. This is nothing new, but we also wanna differentiate the heros as much as possible, so I had to make some changes starting with the Elf.

Barbarian = 4 Att, 6 Def.
Dwarf= 4 Att, 6 Def. 7BP= Disarm Traps.
Elf= 3 Att, 5 Def, 6BP= +1Att to missiles, Multiple shots with Bow, Spells.
Thief = 3 Att, 4 Def, 6BP= 4Att Back Stab with short sword, Disarm Traps, Duel wielding swords, poisons?
Monk= 3 Att, 3 Def, 5BP +1Att for all 2 squar reach weapons(Mdung, pole arms), Some Spells, Roll to Dodge Hazards etc.
Wizard = 2Att, 3Def. Lots of Spells.

Some "bonuses" aren't equal to losing an Attack or Defend Die so my list is just an example. I just gotta figure out what abilities make up for losing those. And MindPoints aren't as useful as BodyPoints so I don't consider their exchange reasonable.

Anyway, my question is, when my missile firing Elf does get a Bow from the armory, what should its max Attack be?
Maybe not better than 3Att & 3Att two shots? That seems a bit much to me.

And a 4Att Crossbow fired every other round since he can't carry a Battle Axe?
His Heal spell might make up for the 2 lost BPs.

Re: Elf & Thief concepts

PostPosted: May 7th, 2024, 10:55 pm
by SirRick
How do the Barbarian and Dwarf have 4 attack dice with 6 defend dice? Are these all custom rules for characters?

Re: Elf & Thief concepts

PostPosted: May 7th, 2024, 11:45 pm
by burglekutt
SirRick wrote:How do the Barbarian and Dwarf have 4 attack dice with 6 defend dice? Are these all custom rules for characters?


I should have mentioned this is with North America(NA) rules &not with later expansions or magical weapons, its just the standard weapons and armor from the armory.
The 4Att Battle Axe & 2Def Plate Mail, Helmet & Shield which makes the hero the most powerful. Total 6Defense dice.

The Dwarfs ability to Disarm Traps is gotta be the most powerful since it can save you and even others from suffering multiple BP damage per quest. I'd trade at least 2BP for it. The Dwarf was smart though and only traded 1BP:)

Having a plus +1DefendDie is better than having a plus +1AttackDie or a 4pt heal spell in my opinion. There's a exchange rate for all these I'd like to figure out.

Re: Elf & Thief concepts

PostPosted: May 8th, 2024, 6:20 am
by SirRick
The heroes cannot use a shield with a battle axe, which is why I was assuming some custom rules. So they should have 4 attack, and 5 defend.

Re: Elf & Thief concepts

PostPosted: May 8th, 2024, 1:59 pm
by burglekutt
SirRick wrote:The heroes cannot use a shield with a battle axe, which is why I was assuming some custom rules. So they should have 4 attack, and 5 defend.

Oh crap! Now I know what you mean, I meant the maximum Attack the hero is capable of during an attack. Or the maximum Defence they can have in general.
For some reason I'm having a hard time wording this! Lol

BARBARIAN = 4 Att, 5/6 Def, 8 BP.
4Att- Battle Axe.
6Def- Plate Mail, Helmet, Shield.
DWARF= 4Att, 5/6Def. 7BP
4Att- Battle Axe.
6Def- Plate Mail, Helmet, Shield.
*Disarm Traps.

ELF= 4Att, 5Def, 6BP.
4Att- Crossbow. 3Att- LongSword/Bow.
5Def- Chain Mail, Helmet, Shield.
*Spells, Multiple shots with Bow.
THIEF = 4Att, 4Def, 6BP.
4Att- BackStab. 3Att- LongSword x 2Att- Short Sword.
4Def- Gamberson, Helmet.
*Disarm Traps, Duel wield, Reroll Thrown daggers, Poisons?

MONK= 3Att, 3Def, 5BP.
3Att- All "2 Square reach" weapons (Mdung, Pole Arms, Halberd).
3Def- Gamberson?
*Some Spells, Roll to "Dodge" Hazards/ Traps etc.
WIZARD = 2Att, 3Def, 4BP.
2Att- Wizards Staff.
3Def- Wizards Cloak.
*Lots of Spells.

You could add all sorts of special abilities to the Thief & Monk but that can come later, for now I'm just trying to get some basic differences in style between them all.

viewtopic.php?f=34&t=6813&p=130957&hilit=Halberd#p130957
Just to clarify, the Monk gets a 3Att all the time with any pole weapon like this^.

Re: Elf & Thief concepts

PostPosted: May 14th, 2024, 3:01 pm
by burglekutt
So what do you guys think of my cast of characters?

Is it ok to take away the Battle Axe & Plate Mail from the Elf and replace it with:
4Att Crossbow every OTHER round & a 3Att Bow (first shot) 2Att (Second shot)?
*3 Spells.

Likewise the Thief gets:
4Att BackStab (Only ONCE per enemy if he can get behind them)?
2Att Thrown Daggers.
Disarm Traps & maybe some Potions?

Monk:
3Att Pole Arms/Halberds (assuming you agree hero's wielding "2Square reach" weapons shouldn't have more than a 2Att)?
Don't roll a :skull: to dodge Traps/ Hazards.
*6 Spells.