Page 1 of 1

Limited Armoury using cards - has anyone done this?

PostPosted: March 17th, 2012, 8:48 am
by Zenithfleet
This is half a question about European/North American differences and half a suggestion for North American players (although I'm sure it's been done before somewhere...)

The EU game comes with equipment cards, while the NA game comes with the Armoury insert. Now, we all know HeroQuest tends to let the Heroes max out their equipment too quickly. I understand the NA edition in particular lets players buy however many weapons they like from the Armoury, so within a few Quests everybody has a crossbow while the lesser items like broadswords get shunned.

I've often wondered if the reason for the European equipment cards was to only allow one instance of each item to be purchased, thus limiting the Heroes' power levels. I can't remember if it says so in the rules, and it doesn't make much sense--seriously, there's only one helmet in the whole country? However, it does encourage wheeling and dealing.

EU players, do you allow people to buy an equipment item only if there's a spare card? Or do you let people buy multiples of the same item?

NA players, I've seen that a few people (e.g. drathe) have developed tiered armouries that only offer certain items in early Quests. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I see this as allowing the Heroes to buy any number of items from a limited pool. (So if you're on Tier 1, you might only make Daggers, Shortswords and Broadswords available, but each player can buy all three if they have the money.) Is this right?

If so, here's an idea: Since the Armoury has been converted to card format on the Olde Inn, has anyone tried offering only a small number of cards to the players at the end of each Quest, representing the equipment 'in stock' at the local town shop?

For instance, after a very early Quest you might lay out five equipment cards--say, two shields, two daggers and a helmet--and announce that the shop only has those items available. Once those two shields are bought, nobody can get any more shields until more arrive in the shop. Meanwhile, super-duper items like the crossbow are on permanent backorder and it's up to the Zargon player to decide when the shop should start offering it--and even then, they probably only get one or two in at a time.

After all, these Heroes spend a lot of time in out-of-the-way places. I doubt they trudge all the way back to the big city after every Quest. They might be forced to rely on small village smithies and discarded soldiers' kit. I can see the Dwarf's reaction already: " 'Ere, mister, this 'elmet has an effing arrow hole in it. Through both sides."

You'd probably want to have at least one really high-priced item on offer too, even in early Quests, to encourage the players to save up for it. "Oh, that shiny thing on the wall there? Yep, genuine Dwarf-made battleaxe, only one this side of Scum River, bargain price..."

Of course, there would have to be some way to resolve arguments if two players wanted to buy the same item...

Re: Limited Armoury using cards - has anyone done this?

PostPosted: March 17th, 2012, 9:50 am
by Goblin-King
We used to play with equipment limited by the cards. But we soon ran into problems as additional equipment were found as treasure during the quests. I seem to remember a spear and a helmet.
That kinda defied the whole purpose of limiting the equipment to one per card. We soon switched to NA style armory with unlimited supply. I see no problem in this. The heroes still die sometimes or are very close.
Remember that all it takes are 2 lucky hits from a chaos warrior and it's game over man! GAME OVER!

The heroes DO tend to get overpowered during the early campaigns, but when you get to the later quests it kinda evens out. Especially if you play with NA body points for the monsters.

As for your ideas... In a HQ style game I'm developing myself the armory is a pile of equipment cards.
After each quest 10 cards are randomly drawn and shown to the players.
That is the armory's inventory. Sometimes it's all good, sometimes it's junk.
The players roll a die to decide the buying order and takes turns to buy something (if they choose to do so)
Works great :-)

Re: Limited Armoury using cards - has anyone done this?

PostPosted: March 17th, 2012, 12:39 pm
by drathe
In the first edition of the EU set, the Equipment cards have two helmets and two shields. (one of each replaced with bracers and the cloak in the second edition) As such, it is my belief that the original intent was to limit the purchasable equipment to the available cards. This would also encourage treasure searches as additional equipment may be found in quests (which the Heroes could sell to their fellows at exorbitant prices). But neither set of rules state any actual limitations.

Re: Limited Armoury using cards - has anyone done this?

PostPosted: March 17th, 2012, 3:34 pm
by Sjeng
Goblin-King wrote:We used to play with equipment limited by the cards. But we soon ran into problems as additional equipment were found as treasure during the quests. I seem to remember a spear and a helmet.
That kinda defied the whole purpose of limiting the equipment to one per card. We soon switched to NA style armory with unlimited supply. I see no problem in this. The heroes still die sometimes or are very close.

That's what we do.
Goblin-King wrote:Remember that all it takes are 2 lucky hits from a chaos warrior and it's game over man! GAME OVER!

Aliens is such a cool movie xD I almost heard you say that.

Re: Limited Armoury using cards - has anyone done this?

PostPosted: March 18th, 2012, 3:38 am
by Zenithfleet
drathe wrote:In the first edition of the EU set, the Equipment cards have two helmets and two shields. (one of each replaced with bracers and the cloak in the second edition) As such, it is my belief that the original intent was to limit the purchasable equipment to the available cards. This would also encourage treasure searches as additional equipment may be found in quests (which the Heroes could sell to their fellows at exorbitant prices). But neither set of rules state any actual limitations.


Aha! That would explain it. I always wondered why there was a bonus shield somewhere in that first questbook... If only they'd put in a few duplicates. I guess two more cards per box adds up to a lot of dead trees, though.

Re: Limited Armoury using cards - has anyone done this?

PostPosted: March 20th, 2012, 6:48 pm
by Thrawn
Zenithfleet wrote:
drathe wrote:In the first edition of the EU set, the Equipment cards have two helmets and two shields. (one of each replaced with bracers and the cloak in the second edition) As such, it is my belief that the original intent was to limit the purchasable equipment to the available cards. This would also encourage treasure searches as additional equipment may be found in quests (which the Heroes could sell to their fellows at exorbitant prices). But neither set of rules state any actual limitations.


Aha! That would explain it. I always wondered why there was a bonus shield somewhere in that first questbook... If only they'd put in a few duplicates. I guess two more cards per box adds up to a lot of dead trees, though.


Good thing we can just print cards off this site. I never had equipment cards before, but I printed off 4 sets (I suppose I really only needed 3), so that there will be enough cards for all characters to be able to have any card necessary. I may do random draws of cards for equipment available, and may weight it towards cheaper equipment at least early, but I'm undecided.