Now, if I take this:
Gold Bearer wrote:Okay box A contains 100,000.
PLUS this:
mitchiemasha wrote:For me this is one of those questions that has no right or wrong answer... Mainly as that computer does not exist. The question is designed to see how you subconsciously think (with out realising unless you've thought deeply into it) how the universe works.
Box A always has 1000 init box b either has 100 or 1,000,000. Either the amount can change based on your choice or the amount will stay the same, which is the model of the universe do you think exists?
If you take both boxes you believe the universe works in away that belief has no influence. Because, if there was 1,000,000 in box b there always will of been that much in the box, regardless to your choice. Same for if it is 100.
if you take box B, you believe belief does have influence, your choice can change the amount in the box.
I suppose it all depends on at what point or who puts the money in the box. If the question says the computer will put in 100 or 1,000,000 it changes the problem.
then I all of a sudden turn from a believer to a disbeliever because of the sum of dough in box A because indeed I probably would choose both boxes if A's sum wasn't so small.
Am I an opportunist by design?
On second thought, I'd still go only for box B as long as its more positive contents is higher than the suggested sum of A and B if I choose both, no matter how small the difference.
I still see the logic in my process.